Bowling Achievement
| 1958 | Marty Cassio | 1974 | Frank Caruso | 1985 | Edward Koneski | 2000 | Scott Ettinger |
| 1959 | Felix Gelhausen | 1975 | Michael Schaffer | 1986 | Steve Pancurak | 2002 | Harry Hamenia |
| 1960 | Charles Lamperti | 1975 | Sam DeParre | 1987 | Richard Hunton | 2002 | Peter Neal |
| 1961 | Joseph Potts | 1975 | Fred Henninger | 1988 | Christian Magory | 2004 | James Charles |
| 1962 | John Dayon | 1976 | Warren Griffin | 1988 | Hank Martin | 2004 | Christopher Freel |
| 1963 | Whitney Munn | 1976 | Dave Tillou | 1989 | Thomas Meade | 2006 | Michael Farinelli |
| 1964 | Leonard Sauer | 1977 | Edward Noga | 1989 | Robert Kontra | 2006 | Michael Reasoner |
| 1965 | Albert Stranich | 1977 | Philip Testa | 1990 | Gordy Coletti Jr. | 2008 | Frank Dickinson |
| 1966 | Frank Figurelli | 1978 | Sam Hays | 1991 | Albert Pruden | 2008 | Anthony Leone |
| 1967 | Gordy Coletti Sr. | 1978 | John Straniero | 1991 | Robert Sippel Jr. | ||
| 1968 | William Miller | 1979 | John Gualtieri | 1992 | Frank Leo | ||
| 1969 | Fred Searry | 1979 | Walt Pulchlopek | 1992 | Robert Shreve | ||
| 1970 | Richard Knapp | 1980 | Al Levens | 1993 | Wright House | ||
| 1971 | James Agresta | 1980 | Sal Notar | 1994 | Gerhard Hornung | ||
| 1972 | Joseph Brown | 1981 | Werner Kursawe | 1994 | Thomas Tavalaro | ||
| 1972 | Phil Visco | 1982 | William Chase | 1996 | Angelo Lardieri | ||
| 1972 | William Townley | 1982 | Joseph LaSpata | 1996 | Chuck Soos | ||
| 1973 | Rocky DeFrancesco | 1983 | Wilbur Stichter | 1998 | Mark Bleiweis | ||
| 1973 | Edward Tietz | 1984 | Ed Pienciak | 1998 | Richard Garon | ||
| 1974 | Robert Sholtis | 1984 | Howie Beekman | 2000 | Tony McCoy |
Meritorious Service
| 1963 | Dave Barr | 1976 | Milt Farb | 1990 | Richard Hoos | |
| 1964 | Lipman Duckat | 1977 | Angelo Archiniaco | 1991 | Arthur Kovar | |
| 1965 | William Schmidt | 1977 | Theodore Flis | 1991 | Les Krichman | |
| 1966 | Tom Cestone | 1978 | Jack Best | 1992 | Frank Palmer | |
| 1966 | George Gardner | 1979 | Len Spanjersberg | 1993 | George Colburn | |
| 1967 | George Hays | 1980 | Joseph LaGregor | 1994 | Howard Taylor | |
| 1967 | Clarence Downey | 1980 | Stephen Trella | 1996 | Harriet Taback | |
| 1968 | Rueben Borinsky | 1981 | Harold Kinney | 1998 | Howard Kressler | |
| 1968 | Louis Marks | 1982 | Daniel Williams Sr. | 2000 | Robert Hodoske | |
| 1969 | Edward J. Woods | 1982 | John Keimig | 2000 | Richard Regan | |
| 1970 | Sam Tarlowe | 1983 | Edward Katz | 2002 | Roosevelt Gant | |
| 1970 | Al Sawicki | 1984 | William Linge | 2002 | Bernard Christ | |
| 1971 | Harry Sturke | 1984 | Gerald Liebeskind | 2004 | Jack Gonter | |
| 1971 | Victor Hesse | 1985 | Robert Judge | 2004 | Michael Tripka | |
| 1972 | John Fatigati | 1985 | Curtis Drake | 2006 | Alonzo "Al" Bridges | |
| 1972 | William Reithel | 1986 | Anthony D'Agostino | 2006 | Gerald Roessle | |
| 1973 | Vince Reynolds | 1986 | Paul Travinsky | 2008 | Charlie Dekowski | |
| 1973 | Randall Ross | 1987 | George Clark | 2008 | Michael Kuzma |
|
| 1974 | Albert Metz | 1987 | George Streng | |||
| 1975 | Herbert Schutt | 1988 | Robert Sobon | |||
| 1975 | Frank DellaRagione | 1989 | Jewel Collins | |||
| 1976 | Howard Buchholz | 1989 | Wenzel Dousa |
Veterans Category
| 1970 | Steve Drozdo | 1977 | Larry Siana | 1986 | Charles Halpin |
| 1971 | Charles McGinley | 1978 | Dr. Edward Warren | 1986 | Bruno Golda |
| 1972 | Jacob Forster | 1979 | Vic Baker | 1987 | George Dorin |
| 1972 | Raymond Lusardi | 1980 | Chic Chicarelli | 1988 | Adolph Maulshagen |
| 1973 | Theodore Lance | 1980 | Peter Hnat | 1988 | Robert Marshall |
| 1973 | Blacky Artz | 1980 | Fred Maute | 1988 | Robert Washington |
| 1973 | Tom Siana | 1981 | Nick Sverchek | 1989 | Armond Cotugno |
| 1974 | William McQueston | 1981 | Charles Rotunno | 1990 | Walter Baldessarre |
| 1974 | Gil Cosgren | 1982 | Eugene Hering | 1991 | Michael Ribnicki |
| 1975 | Raymond J. Ogier | 1982 | Joseph Macaluso | 1998 | Iggy DeBella |
| 1975 | Vic Groppe | 1982 | Edward Golda | 1998 | Tony Grande |
| 1976 | Stan Kielbasa | 1983 | Anthony Foti | 2000 | Edward J. Stoerger |
| 1976 | Walter Natkie | 1984 | Xaier DeHaas | 2002 | Wade Wheaton |
| 1977 | George Yorke | 1985 | Edmund Stryker | 2006 | Michael Bedkowski |
| 1977 | Sol Berman | 1985 | John DeStefanis |
Posthumous Bowling Achievement
| 1962 | Frank Seaton | 1969 | Frank McElhone | 1977 | Earl Bixby |
| 1963 | William Miller Sr. | 1970 | Alfred Hanson | 1979 | Joseph Figurelli Sr. |
| 1964 | Stanley Slomenski | 1971 | George Reinfurt | 1987 | Richard Young Sr. |
| 1965 | Al Weber | 1971 | Harold Reitemeyer | 1990 | Charles Lazotti |
| 1966 | Frank Grippe | 1972 | Robert Trowbridge | 1994 | Edmund McGettigan |
| 1967 | William Krauss | 1974 | Jack O'Dell | ||
| 1968 | Michael Murzinski | 1975 | Jerry O'Donnell |
Posthumous Meritorious Service
| 1963 | Joe Seery | 1971 | Edward Loeser | 1981 | Donald Dodge |
| 1964 | John McManus | 1972 | Charles Havanki | 1983 | Jake Esocoff |
| 1965 | Mal Hurley | 1973 | Dick Rockford | 1987 | John Martin |
| 1966 | August Sobon | 1974 | Chris Zusi | 1990 | Peter Schiessl |
| 1967 | Nicholas Primiano | 1975 | Gene Hampson | 1993 | Anderson Ferguson |
| 1968 | Armondo Finizio | 1977 | Anthony Bilinskis | 1996 | Richard Pakulski |
| 1970 | Carl Mueller | 1978 | Adam Flis | ||
| 1970 | John Givens | 1979 | Paul Rottstock |